Known issueHow-toUpdated · 3 replies on Steam
FreshWomen - Season 1: Alyssa Can Be Screwed Only Once? I Didn't Get Third Date Love…
Short answer
Suggested fix (unconfirmed): Replay the scene and select different choices.
The problem
I stayed with alyssa and there was a dialogue about how this a third date and more, but I didn't get the achievement if that's what that one is about. I assume this is not a bug because apparently she's the only person you can screw once and only at the end of the game.
What players suggest
I had the same issue at first. Try replaying the scene again and play it with different choices. This worked for me.
Did this work for you?
Source: original Steam Community discussion. Quotes are shortened; all credit goes to the posters. Tags: achievement